SHALL WE DANCE?
A few years ago I watched the movie Shall We Dance with Richard Gere, Susan Sarandon (one of my favourite actresses) and Jennifer Lopez (who I normally don’t like). The movie was enjoyable but not hugely memorable for most.
It’s about a man (Gere) who is in a bit of a midlife crisis and while journeying home on the train – usually laborious and tedious – looks out the window and sees a woman dancing (Lopez). He decides to check it out, and discovers that she teaches a small dance class. He joins the class and finds a new lease on life.
He doesn’t tell his wife (Sarandon) though and she immediately suspects his late nights and renewed vigour are the result of a new woman in his life. She mistakenly believes he’s having a sordid affair and hires a private investigator.
The PI quite fancies her and at one stage it looks like they’re about to have an affair, but Sarandon’s character stands firm in her marriage. The PI is confused (and quite jaded since he spends most of his time following cheating spouses) and asks her why people get married. Her response is the reason for this piece. And my favourite quote ever. And the reason I love the movie.
I’ll get to what she says soon, but I’m still on the gay issue…
Recently, I went on to a church’s website. It’s a church I was actively involved in and left after I realised I was not winning the ex-gay battle. They were not the most supportive with my decision to come to terms with my sexuality, but I suppose they never knew how to deal with it.
On the website they have an article asking “Is God homophobic?” I read it and, at first, was angry, and then sad. In a nutshell, the writer concludes that: homosexuals are loved; that turning straight is not really an option (one step forward, people!); and thus the only solution for gays who want to be Christian is celibacy.
I’m not sure people that who aren’t gay know what that means. Being a gay man is not something I chose; I don’t believe anyone does, or would. And realising you are gay and constructively dealing with it means you go through a grieving process.
You grieve the fact that you are different. You grieve that you are going to be in a minority group that experiences exclusion… You grieve that you are seen by some as dirty… You grieve your masculinity or more correctly the loss of masculinity in the perception of others…
And, the one that I still get sad about, you grieve that you will never have children and a “traditional” family within which to raise children. Adoption or signing a contract with surrogate mother is the only option…
But, you grieve…
Now this church tells me I also have to grieve not having a partner… someone to love… someone to grow old with. You see, when asked why people get married Sarandon’s character says this:
“We need a witness to our lives. There’s a billion people on the planet… I mean, what does any one life really mean? But in a marriage, you’re promising to care about everything. The good things, the bad things, the terrible things, the mundane things… all of it, all of the time, every day. You’re saying ‘Your life will not go unnoticed because I will notice it. Your life will not go un-witnessed because I will be your witness…’”
I know some will say that God’s love and witness is sufficient. I don’t believe it is. And it certainly isn’t enough for the vast majority of straight people. God put us on earth to experience relationships.
So now, if I choose to have a partner, does that mean I have to grieve the loss of a relationship with God? Well I don’t believe that either…
I choose life – and life in abundance. And I choose to have someone I love to witness it, to be a part of my everyday life… and to be a witness to his.
That’s all it boils down to.
atlast something good and beautiful to read on mamba
I agree!. What a great article! I agree completely. I am a Christian and I regularly pray for a life partner. Someone who will witness my life..
Why is it that those of us who really long for an understanding life partner…..do not find such a person?
Awesome topic!!. Very very nice topic – and agreed on the movie. Wasn’t something I’d watch over and over again, but that quote stuck with me for a while!!
Sorry to say, but I think you’re missing the plot with your article “Shall we dance?”.
There are three elements to be discussed (and not confused):
1) God
2) Religion
3) Homosexuality
Let’s get the elephant out of the room as a departure point. The sooner you separate religion (i.e. ”the church”) from “God” the better. Rather stand back and start thinking for yourself and bring into question the Calvinistic cloak you were raised in with the auspices of Church and Religion.
Homosexuality does not equal grieving! Your five grieving points do not hold water for many gay men – especially the ”have children” part.
Further on the homosexuality front, you step right in the direction of homophobia with your statement “Being a gay man is not something I chose; I don’t believe anyone does, or would.” Correct me if I’m wrong, are you not looking at homosexuality with the exact perspective than that of your ex-church where you had your ”ex-gay battle”? I guess I’m not the ”anyone” you refer to, because if I could choose my sexuality again, I would choose it exactly as it is – GAY – because there is nothing wrong with it to begin with.
Now that you can think free from this mentally suffocating dogma instilled through Church and Religion you will have no fear of living your life as you choose or with any guilt going along with that.
Start thinking and stop believing what Church and Religion dishes out without questioning. Maybe just then will you be able to figure out life, gay or straight, within this amazing Universe.
well spoken, lol!
response to comment. Appreciate the comment and your views. I’ve responded to this comment on my blog:
ramblerclive.blogspot.com
Blog comment. Re: Church saying gay is only an option if celibate – wtf!!! That is insane. I agree whole-heartedly with your thoughts on that one. That church-goer’s view is the kind of bullshit that keeps me out of churches. But I do believe that they are not all like that.
Lastly and most pertinent to my life right now, the GRIEVING process. I am slap-bang in the middle of that right now. And I am so grateful to you for identifying and normalising it. I have been walking around with this huge sense of loss, which had been exacerbated by the guilt of feeling this way (raises questions of potential internalised homophobia???).
I’m looking forward to emerging out of the grief one day.
Thank-you for speaking OUT, LOUD and PROUD.
…. So well written clive. Thanks for this.
All your thoughts. What a nice topic – well written and nice responses to from everybody.
well done